Judge Rules “Big Pimpin” Lawsuit Against Jay Z Can Move Forward
It had appeared that the statute of limitations for a legal copyright claim to the song “Khosara Khosara” had expired. The new ruling now allows the case to continue because the licensing deal between EMI and the Egyptain company Sout El Phan ended in 2006.
Since “Big Pimpin’” was used on television, movies, and live performances after ’06, the court suggested Hamdy’s nephew Osama Ahmed Fahmy pursue further legal discovery to determine if Jay and other defendants infringed on the copyright of “Khosara Khosara” at that time.
U.S. District Judge Christina Snyder wrote:
The Court finds plaintiff’s argument persuasive, and concludes that plaintiff should be permitted to conduct discovery as to what defendants knew during the post-expiration period. Further discovery is appropriate because plaintiff need only show that defendants knew that they were infringing some copyright in Khosara Khosara in order to defeat laches; plaintiff need not show that defendants were aware that they were infringing plaintiff’s copyright.